The Up and Up

The Up and Up

50-year mortgage? Gen Z isn’t buying it.

MAGA youth reject the president’s latest housing idea – the latest sign of a growing rift between President Trump and the young voters who supported him in 2024.

Nov 13, 2025
∙ Paid

Affordability. Cost of living. Rent. Housing. These aren’t just political buzzwords, they’re daily obstacles for all Americans, but especially young ones. Young people are confronting increasingly expensive *everything*. High rent, unaffordable college education, and shaky job prospects are just a few of their most pressing economic concerns. Saddled with student loans (and unsure if a traditional college degree will actually pay off in an AI-dominated world), young Americans are wary of taking on long-term debt. The American Dream is obviously changing. It’s not that Gen Z doesn’t value traditional life goals like higher education, marriage, children, or home ownership — those milestones are just increasingly inaccessible.

The Up and Up is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Zohran Mamdani tapped into this reality in New York City and struck a chord with young people across the country as a result. Now, other politicians are taking note.

Most notably, President Donald Trump. In a Truth social post, Trump pitched a 50-year mortgage, conceivably something that was supposed to signal he’s listening to young Americans on housing and make it appear more affordable to young buyers by spreading payments over a longer period. But it didn’t hit.

It’s the latest in a series of moves that have left Trump voters increasingly disillusioned. Couple that with anti-Trump rhetoric from right-wing influencers like the controversial Nick Fuentes (who declared this week that “MAGA is dead”), and things aren’t looking so hot for Trump, who was praised this time a year ago for his ability to connect with young men especially.

According to YouGov:

  • Trump had a 44.6.% favorability rating with registered voters under 30 last January.

  • Now, that number is at 34%.

When you look at YouGov’s tracker on young men specifically:

  • Trump had a 55.7% favorability rating with registered young men under 30 when he took office in January.

  • Now, that number is 47.1%.

This week, I checked in with Trump 2024 voters in The Up and Up Community — men and women — to hear their thoughts on his 50-year mortgage idea.

Not a single one I spoke to is for it.

I also asked how they’re feeling about his second term more broadly. The results were mixed. Some remain bullish. One said Trump 2.0 feels like “betrayal.”

He put it bluntly:

“My anger on his words and decisions recently is something I’ve never felt for a politician.”

Here’s what I heard.

🔑 What You’ll Unlock: Highlights from this edition

  • Quotes from a former Trump supporter

  • Why a 50-year mortgage is perceived as a “bandaid on a gaping wound”

  • My take on young voters’ fickle loyalty

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Rachel Janfaza
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture