Political pundits and campaign operatives often assume thereâs a clear-cut playbook to reach every demographic of voters.
And after the 2024 election, that type of thinking was directed squarely at young men, who took a hard right turn in 2024, backing President Donald Trump over former Vice President Kamala Harris by a 14-point margin. That marked quite a difference from 2020, when young men backed former President Joe Biden over Trump by a 15-point margin.
The sudden swing prompted a swift debate â What had happened with these hard-to-pin-down Gen Z men? Had they all bought into Trumpâs version of masculinity â one that manosphere podcasters had amplified and leaned into? Were they now all hard-core MAGA voters, ruby red Republicans? Or could Democrats win them back? And if so, how?
In the months that followed, Democrats sought to connect with young men in their own way, talking about sports, going on podcasts that Trump had visited in 2024, and even starting their own shows.
Turns out, Democrats could win young men again, and they did. Young men swung 40 points back toward Democrats last week, according to The New York Times, backing Democratic candidates for the U.S. House of Representatives by a 26-point margin.
Of course, young men werenât alone in moving back toward Democrats after firmly buying into Trumpâs 2024 campaign promises â many of which have been ignored or flat out rejected.
But the quick flip-flop amongst this cohort begs the question of how we got from obsessing over a Trump version of strongman macho-ism to embracing Texas Senator-elect James Talaricoâs softer style of masculinity (or as some refer to it, his soy-boy aesthetic), or even New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdaniâs liberal bro aura.
The problem is that so much of the discourse around young men after the 2024 election has assumed that all young men want the same version of masculinity reflected at them. And I worry that after Democratsâ success last week, weâre repeating the same mistakes now with the same voting bloc, just on the other side of the political spectrum.
In an attempt to make up for the MAGA-ified version of manhood or to find an answer for why young men swung so starkly in the opposite direction last week, thereâs been an overemphasis on the left with Democratic men like Mamdani and â after last weekâs blue wave â next-gen figures on the left like Georgia Senator Jon Ossoff, Montanaâs newly elected Rep. Sam Forstag, Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed, or of course, the breakout star of this yearâs elections: Talarico.
The conversation about this voting bloc is once again reverting to identity, focusing on how conventionally attractive many of these newly elected Democrats are, analyzing their relationships with their significant others, how they dress, and their sense of âmanliness.â
But truth be told, young men donât care about perceived âmasculinity.â Theyâre perhaps the swingiest of cohorts â and most arenât interested in slapping a political label by their name. Instead, they care about what their elected officials will do for them, and how they will meaningfully improve their lives.
As a 19-year-old man told me in a focus group just one day after the midterms, when it comes to politics, heâs looking for: âLower prices, gas. I just want a better quality of living.â
This year, Democrats regained clout with young men by focusing on that â but that doesnât mean these young men are loyal or that their preferences will last.
The plight of young men today is real, and not one to be taken lightly. While traditional gender norms still prevail, young women are outpacing young men across a range of metrics.
Young women are going to and graduating from college at higher rates than young men.
Single women are more likely to own homes than their male counterparts.
And in some U.S. cities, young women are out-earning young men.
Plus, young menâs unemployment rate is rising at the same time that their labor force participation has dropped.
Meanwhile, young womenâs labor force participation outpaces that of generations of women that came before them.
In turn, young men today have come to resent the idea they are benefitting from generations of patriarchy that came before them â because in many ways to them, it doesnât feel like they are.
After 2024, political pundits and operatives thought that Trumpâs version of masculinity â one rooted in an aspirational obsession with money, distaste with political correctness, and a sense that the problems young men face today are completely external to them (and instead, solely the fault of others) was the key to reaching these disaffected young men. Because in 2024, it did. And that embodiment of masculinity was amplified by a cast of characters including everyone from billionaire Elon Musk to influencer boxer Jake Paul. This vision was something even Metaâs Mark Zuckerberg seemed to embrace in the aftermath of Trumpâs 2024 victory.
But over the past two years, as the sheen of Trump 2.0 has worn off, many of the men who promised a renewed sense of American opulence and financial results for the young men they courted so aggressively have proved their âmasculinityâ was mostly a performance. If masculinity truly meant economic success and a better quality of life for this demographic, the version that was promised failed â and young men took note.
The cost of living is rising, the threat of AI is real, and corruption have become top constituent concerns â as a select few very wealthy men (including the president himself as well as many others in his orbit) seem to be profiting off decisions that dictate financial outcomes for everybody else, without their buy-in or benefit.
Meanwhile, Trump has firmly embraced the establishment he spent years railing against, planning efforts for a new White House ballroom, refusing to fully release the Epstein Files, and involving the US in foreign war â raising prices at home and costing human lives abroad.
In turn, young men have realized that the conventional ideals of âmasculinityâ Trump ran on mean nothing if they arenât rooted in character, respect, and ultimately, results.
Itâs not rocket science. Young men arenât asking politicians to perform some made-for-social-media version of being a man, and the reality is that masculinity looks different for everyone. But weâve collectively placed far too much attention and emphasis on caricatures of what it means to âbe a manâ â from Elon Musk to looksmaxxing influencer Clavicular and Joe Rogan.
The 2026 elections proved that young voters donât care about identity when there are more immediate concerns. Instead, theyâre more focused on pressing issues â like the cost of living, war, AI, and corruption â as well as how candidates talk about these issues, and how these candidates show up in the communities theyâre meant to represent, both online and in person.
Looking at the numbers, Talarico pulled off a 67-point shift toward Democrats from 2024 with young men in Texas. Thatâs the largest swing toward a Democrat among men under 30 in any battleground Senate race. And looking at the entire Senate map, South Carolinaâs Annie Andrews and Jon Ossoff saw the next biggest shifts with young men, pulling off a 65-point shift and a 62-point shift toward Democrats from 2024 with men under 30 respectively.
Senator-elect Andrews, a 46-year-old pediatrician and mom, doesnât exactly fit the stereotype of the messenger best-positioned to connect with young men in a post 2024-election landscape. But young men voted for her in droves because she ran a campaign focused on standing up for South Carolinians and lowering costs to make life in her home state more affordable.
Ossoff, whoâs 39, went hard on corruption, including that at the hands of Trump and his administration, leaning into exactly how the financial decisions of this president have made the average American worse off.
And Talarico, a 37-year-old pastor and former teacher, won young men over by leaning into a message of unity. As a 26-year-old man from Illinois shared with me in a pre-election focus group, he appreciated that Talarico âleads [with] love.â For a generation that only knows a toxic political culture and is ready for something different, that resonated.
Looking to 2028, young men are not Democratsâ voters to lose. Theyâre entirely up for grabs, and theyâre any candidates to gain.
Moving forward, it would be wise for any candidate looking to win this cohort to start talking about opportunities for young men, especially those looking for work in an economy increasingly dominated by AI. There are plenty of good paying and available jobs in fields that have been traditionally occupied by women â from teachers, to nurses, and medical assistants. And there are also high-paying trade jobs that are unfortunately still far too stigmatized. Iâd posit that successful 2028 contenders will have a plan for finding more young people jobs by leaning into these industries. They should also build proposals around helping them afford their rent and setting themselves up to achieve long-term financial stability.
Perhaps weâve spent too much time hyper-fixating on what young men are seeing in their social media feeds, and on a politics of grievance, and not enough time on tangible solutions to impact their lives in person â yes, by focusing on increasing job pathways for them and their friends in the near future, but also, by just being human.
Noteworthy Reads and Listens
Reads: Why Young âAmerica Firstâ Conservatives Turned Against Trump, Simon Van Zuylen-wood for New York Magazine, How Do I Teach My Daughter That Robots Are Not Her Friend, Elizabeth Endicott for The Cut, The Rise of the Gen Z Cinephile, Melena Ryzik for The New York Times, How Gen Z Is Becoming the Entrepreneurship Generation, Vanessa Fuhrmans for The Wall Street Journal
Listens: I joined Brittany Luse on NPRâs Itâs Been a Minute for a conversation about Gen Z in the midterms. Listen here: We need to rethink what we know about young voters.


